Nick Train’s Flagship Fund Finds Its Footing in the Software Bet

Nick Train's flagship fund has recorded the strongest month of its 20-year life. The £1bn Lindsell Train UK Equity fund returned 10.8% in October, its best month relative to peers, according to Morningstar, and its second-best in absolute terms since the 2006 launch, after five years of underperformance and a difficult first half for the manager, who also runs the £808m Finsbury Growth and Income Trust. In a letter to investors Train presented the month as a possible turning point rather than a good quarter, with the recovery resting on the software holdings most investors had given up on.
Picture of Elizabeth Jenkins-Smalley

Elizabeth Jenkins-Smalley

Editor In Chief at The Executive Magazine

Share this article:

Nick Train’s flagship fund has recorded the strongest month of its 20-year life, and the reason sits in the part of the portfolio most investors had given up on. The £1 billion Lindsell Train UK Equity fund returned 10.8% to investors in October, its best month relative to peers and its second-best in absolute terms since its 2006 launch.

The recovery follows five years of underperformance and a difficult first half for the manager, who also runs the £808 million FTSE 250 Finsbury Growth and Income Trust. In a letter to Lindsell Train investors, Train presented the month as a possible turning point rather than a favourable quarter.

Why the software bet turned

The sell-off that created the opening

Earlier this year investors sold software companies indiscriminately, in a rout the market came to call the SaaSpocalypse, on the fear that artificial intelligence would undercut the seat-based pricing that makes those businesses so profitable. Finsbury posted a 14.4% loss in the six months to April, and Train’s funds carried consecutive months of losses.

Train held his ground. He had built unusually large positions in Relx, Experian, the London Stock Exchange Group and Sage, and those four holdings account for more than 40% of a deliberately concentrated portfolio. Relx and Sage have rallied more than 50% since their lows in late February, and shares in Relx, Experian and Sage all rose by more than 20% in October after Experian and Sage issued more positive trading updates.

Concentration as a conscious choice

Concentration of that kind cuts both ways, and holders have felt the sharp edge of it. Four positions above 40% of a fund mean that a sector-wide sell-off bites quickly and a sector-wide recovery pays quickly, which is precisely what the past eight months have shown.

‘The better performance results from a rally in major portfolio holdings that have been under share price pressure over the last 18 months,’ Train wrote. ‘In other words, rightly or wrongly, we did not capitulate during that period of underperformance and sell these holdings and this means we have, at least, captured their bounce for fundholders.’

The question for executives buying software

AI as a benefit rather than a threat

Train rejects the reading that his portfolio is a defensive position against the technology cycle. ‘Crucially we continue to maintain that, in fact, our digital companies are not losers from AI; instead, we think they will more likely be multi-year beneficiaries from it,’ he wrote, adding that he hopes the month marks ‘an inflection point in investor sentiment toward our holdings that could presage a long period of better returns’.

That argument matters well beyond one fund. Boards weighing multi-year software contracts are being asked by suppliers to accept that embedded workflow, proprietary reference information and regulatory record make a product hard to replace, and that AI adds value to those assets rather than eroding them. Train’s wager is that the market undervalued exactly that case, and procurement teams are now testing it contract by contract, with renewal terms, data ownership clauses and exit costs under closer examination than at any point in the past three years.

A record tested by the consumer slowdown

The long record is what bought Train the patience to wait. Since he took over Finsbury in December 2000 the trust has generated returns of nearly 750%, roughly double the return of the wider market, a performance that earned him the label of Britain’s Warren Buffett. Since the pandemic the funds have lagged peers, weighed down by consumer goods holdings such as Diageo and Unilever.

Morningstar’s assessment of October places Finsbury as the best-performing investment trust of the month, with shares up 11.8%. They remain 5% lower across a five-year view, which is a reminder that one strong month repairs sentiment faster than it repairs a record. For directors and investors reading the letter, the useful lesson is less about stock selection than about how conviction is documented, tested and explained while it is out of favour, since that is the period when an investment case is either defended with evidence or quietly abandoned.

Latest Stories

Continue reading