EHRC Calls Time on Salary History Questions in UK Hiring

The Equality and Human Rights Commission wants ministers to stop employers asking candidates for salary history, part of a wider push on pay transparency. Penny East, chief executive of the Fawcett Society, argues that an old payslip records only what a worker once accepted, never their worth, and that women's earnings are already shaped by the gender pay gap and career breaks. Scott Winter, co-founder of Agility EOR, prefers published salary ranges. The fix costs employers nothing: set the band before the first interview and let the offer rest on the job in front of them rather than the payslip behind them.
Picture of Elizabeth Jenkins-Smalley

Elizabeth Jenkins-Smalley

Editor In Chief at The Executive Magazine

Share this article:

Why the EHRC wants salary history out of hiring

The Equality and Human Rights Commission is urging ministers to stop employers demanding salary history from job applicants, as part of a wider drive on pay transparency. The watchdog wants firms to publish salaries in job adverts and to be barred from requiring candidates to reveal their previous pay packets. For the executives who run those firms, the proposal is best read as a prompt to tighten up how offers are built, not a new burden to fear. The most forward-thinking employers are already pricing roles on their own merits.

At the heart of the argument sits a simple question: should what someone earned yesterday determine what they are offered tomorrow? The EHRC believes it should not. Its intervention has drawn support from equal pay campaigners and practical caution from hiring specialists, and ministers now face a decision on how far the rules should go.

Pay set by the role, not the past

Penny East, chief executive of the Fawcett Society, argues that a previous salary reveals only what a worker once accepted, never an objective measure of their worth. She points out that women’s earnings are already shaped by the gender pay gap, career breaks, reduced hours and workplace practices that have historically favoured men. Basing a new salary on what a candidate was paid before, she argues, allows inequality to follow them from job to job.

For employers, the correction is refreshingly cheap. Ms East dismisses any suggestion that the reform would burden business, noting that a salary history ban would not cost employers money or demand lengthy new strategies and plans. It would simply ask firms to stop doing something that cannot be justified or explained.

Practical steps business leaders can take now

Price the job before interviews begin

Pay, on this view, should be set according to the demands of the role, using criteria such as skills, experience and responsibility. Executives can ask their HR teams to define salary bands for every opened role before the first interview is booked. When the right person is found, the offer then rests on an objective assessment of the job in front of them rather than the payslip behind them.

Advertise the range and let candidates negotiate within it

Scott Winter, co-founder of the employer-of-record firm Agility EOR, makes the case that publishing a salary range in the job advert answers the problem more directly than a ban ever could. Candidates would know the parameters in advance and negotiate within them, removing the guessing game on both sides of the table. Openness pays dividends for employers too. Firms that reveal their ranges early avoid spending months in recruitment only for an offer to fall short and lose the preferred candidate at the final hurdle.

What to watch out for along the way

Voluntary disclosure can still skew the process

Mr Winter cautions that a poorly handled ban could hold back the very candidates it is designed to help. Applicants would remain free to share their current salary voluntarily, and American experience suggests better-paid candidates are the most willing to do so. Quieter applicants may then be presumed to earn less, whatever the rules say, which is why the process around the ban matters as much as the ban itself.

The practical response sits well within any leadership team’s reach. Keep interview scripts and application forms consistent, train interviewers not to probe for pay information, and weigh every candidate against the same published criteria. A little process discipline keeps offers fair while the legislation catches up.

Advertised ranges alone will not finish the job

The EHRC’s position acknowledges that broad bands in adverts are only part of the answer. Even where an advert carries a range, previous pay can still be used to nudge a candidate towards the bottom of it, which is why the watchdog backs the outright ban alongside greater transparency. Firms that move early on objective pay criteria may find the transition easier than expected.

A reputational gain for employers that move first

For boards and business leaders, transparent, objectively priced pay is quietly becoming a reputational asset. Candidates increasingly expect to know the range before they apply, and firms that provide one stand out in crowded talent markets. Whatever ministers decide about the salary history ban, the direction of public debate is clear: British hiring is moving towards pricing the job rather than the past, and organisations that prepare now will make the change look effortless.

Latest Stories

Continue reading